Legal Insights

Plain-language guides and case briefs on Philippine law — researched from the firm's law library of 184,000+ statutes, Supreme Court decisions, and agency issuances, and written so non-lawyers can understand and act on them.

Showing 25452568 of 3,944 articles for supreme court

Who Is in Delay in Reciprocal Obligations? Philippine Contract of Sale Disputes

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when delay begins in reciprocal obligations under a contract of sale, and why mutual default cancels out.

Res Judicata in Philippine Land Disputes: Why a Reconstitution Case Doesn't Block Ownership Claims

A title reconstitution case doesn't settle ownership. Learn how res judicata applies in Philippine land disputes and protects your property rights.

Liability for Flood Damage: Private vs Public Drainage Systems

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when a lessor is liable for flood damage—distinguishing private drainage maintenance from public sewer responsibility.

When Fear Is Not Enough: Unlawful Aggression in Philippine Self-Defense Cases

Philippine law requires actual unlawful aggression for self-defense claims. Learn what counts and what does not under the Revised Penal Code.

Emancipation Patents Indefeasibility and Agrarian Reform Beneficiaries Rights

Supreme Court affirms that Emancipation Patents become indefeasible one year after issuance, protecting farmer-beneficiaries from late cancellation challenges.

State Witness Discharge: Balancing DOJ Authority and Judicial Discretion

The Supreme Court clarifies when the DOJ, not courts, may discharge an accused as state witness under RA 6981.

Usury Law and Contractual Obligations: Striking the Balance in Loan Agreements

The Supreme Court clarifies how the Usury Law interacts with loan restructuring, refinancing, and the binding force of contracts in DBP v. CA.

Authority to Sign Certification Against Forum Shopping in Corporate Litigation

Who may sign the certification against forum shopping in corporate cases? The Supreme Court clarifies the rules on authority and false certifications.

Right to Present Evidence Ensures Fair Trial Despite Counsel's Absence

Supreme Court rules that a client's right to present evidence cannot be sacrificed due to counsel's absence, ensuring fair trial.

Presumption of Regularity Protecting Judges From Baseless Charges and Harassment

Learn how the presumption of regularity shields judges from baseless administrative charges and protects judicial independence.

Consignation and the Debtor's Right to Withdraw: Lessons from Banco Filipino v. Diaz

When can a debtor withdraw a consignated deposit? The Supreme Court explains the rules under Article 1260 of the Civil Code.

Gross Negligence of Counsel Can Justify New Trial in Criminal Cases

When a lawyer's gross negligence deprives an accused of due process, courts may reopen the case for a fair trial.

Lawyer Convicted of Direct Bribery: Acejas III vs. People and the Ethics of Representation

The Supreme Court convicted lawyer Francisco Acejas III of direct bribery for conspiring with a public officer to extort money — a warning to all legal professionals.

Illegal Dismissal Burden of Proof: Employer Must Substantiate Abandonment Claims

In Velasco v. NLRC, the Supreme Court clarified that employers bear the burden of proving abandonment in illegal dismissal cases, and that separation pay does not replace backwages.

Boundary Disputes: Proving Land Ownership in Philippine Courts

A Supreme Court ruling clarifies how courts resolve boundary disputes, emphasizing the importance of approved survey plans and proper identification of property.

Illegal Dismissal: Abandonment Defense Fails, Backwages Still Due

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on illegal dismissal, abandonment defense, and the right to full backwages even when separation pay is awarded.

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies: Why You Must First Navigate Government Channels

Philippine Supreme Court ruling explains why bidders must exhaust administrative remedies under R.A. 9184 before going to court.

Disqualification and Succession in Local Elections: The Sinsuat Case

Explaining the Supreme Court ruling on disqualification of winning candidates, ballot appreciation, and succession rules in Philippine local elections.

Fraud Voids Donations: Protecting Consent in Property Transfers

Philippine Supreme Court ruling on how fraud and misrepresentation invalidate donations, protecting illiterate donors' consent in property transfers.

Unsigned Stipulations in Mortgages: Philippine Supreme Court Upholds Consent as Key

Philippine Supreme Court rules a mortgage stipulation inserted after signing without the mortgagor's consent is void ab initio.

When Government Salaries Can Be Withheld: The Santiago COA Ruling

The Supreme Court clarifies when COA may withhold a government employee's salary for an alleged cash shortage, and when it cannot apply the withheld amounts.

Equitable Mortgage vs Absolute Sale: What Philippine Courts Look For

When is a deed of sale really a mortgage? The Supreme Court explains the rules on equitable mortgage in Cirelos v. Hernandez.

Stare Decisis in Philippine Courts: How Prior Rulings Bind Future Cases

The Supreme Court applies stare decisis to bar relitigation of the Pepsi The decision demonstrates how prior rulings on the same controversy can bar subsequent claims and promote consistency in the ad

Deficiency Judgments in Philippine Foreclosure: Can Banks Recover More After Auction?

Philippine Supreme Court clarifies when banks can collect deficiency after extrajudicial foreclosure of real estate mortgages.